{"id":12306,"date":"2021-04-20T09:49:32","date_gmt":"2021-04-20T07:49:32","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/bpcc.jedie2.vot.pl\/publikacja-bezskutecznosc-wzgledna-umowy-art-59-k-c\/"},"modified":"2022-10-03T14:56:50","modified_gmt":"2022-10-03T12:56:50","slug":"publikacja-bezskutecznosc-wzgledna-umowy-art-59-k-c","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/publikacja-bezskutecznosc-wzgledna-umowy-art-59-k-c\/","title":{"rendered":"Bezskuteczno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119dna umowy (art. 59 k.c.)"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Skar\u00adga pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adska to nie je\u00addy\u00adna in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja Ko\u00addek\u00adsu cy\u00adwil\u00adne\u00adgo ma\u00adj\u0105\u00adca za za\u00adda\u00adnie ochro\u00adn\u0119 wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adli przed frau\u00adda\u00adcyj\u00adny\u00admi dzia\u00ad\u0142a\u00adnia\u00admi d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adk\u00f3w. In\u00adnym in\u00adstru\u00admen\u00adtem praw\u00adnym, wy\u00admie\u00adrzo\u00adnym prze\u00adciw\u00adko oso\u00adbom uni\u00adka\u00adj\u0105\u00adcym wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnia swo\u00adich zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u0144, jest bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna umo\u00adwy z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. In\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja ta na pierw\u00adszy rzut oka mo\u00ad\u017ce wy\u00adda\u00adwa\u0107 si\u0119 \u0142u\u00addz\u0105\u00adco po\u00addob\u00adna do po\u00adw\u00f3dz\u00adtwa pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskie\u00adgo. Wy\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adj\u0105 jed\u00adnak mi\u0119\u00addzy ni\u00admi istot\u00adne r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni\u00adce, kt\u00f3\u00adre mo\u00adg\u0105 mie\u0107 zna\u00adcz\u0105\u00adcy wp\u0142yw na sy\u00adtu\u00adacj\u0119 wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adli.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" style=\"width: 250px; height: 47px;\" src=\"\/old\/old\/uploads\/ckeditor\/pictures\/18612\/content_filipiakbabicz.jpg\" alt=\"\" \/><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Prze\u00ads\u0142an\u00adki za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adnia art. 59 k.c.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Zgod\u00adnie z\u00a0art. 59 zd. 1 k.c. \u201eW ra\u00adzie za\u00adwar\u00adcia umo\u00adwy, kt\u00f3\u00adrej wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnie czy\u00adni ca\u0142\u00adko\u00adwi\u00adcie lub cz\u0119\u00ad\u015bcio\u00adwo nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwym zado\u015b\u0107uczy\u00adnienie rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu oso\u00adby trze\u00adciej, oso\u00adba ta mo\u00ad\u017ce \u017c\u0105\u00adda\u0107 uzna\u00adnia umo\u00adwy za bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adn\u0105 w\u00a0sto\u00adsun\u00adku do niej, je\u00ad\u017ce\u00adli stro\u00adny o\u00a0jej rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu wie\u00addzia\u00ad\u0142y al\u00adbo je\u00ad\u017ce\u00adli umo\u00adwa by\u00ad\u0142a nie\u00adod\u00adp\u0142at\u00adna\u201d.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Z\u00a0oma\u00adwia\u00adne\u00adgo prze\u00adpi\u00adsu mo\u017c\u00adna wy\u00adwie\u015b\u0107 na\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adj\u0105\u00adce prze\u00ads\u0142an\u00adki nie\u00adzb\u0119d\u00adne dla mo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwo\u00ad\u015bci je\u00adgo za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adnia:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"font-size: 14px;\">oso\u00adba trze\u00adcia mu\u00adsi mie\u0107\u00a0<strong>rosz\u00adcze\u00adnie wo\u00adbec ja\u00adkie\u00adgo\u015b podmio\u00adtu zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adne\u00adgo\u00a0<\/strong>wo\u00adbec niej,<\/span><\/li>\n<li style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong><span style=\"font-size: 14px;\">zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adny mu\u00adsi za\u00adwrze\u0107 z\u00a0in\u00adn\u0105 oso\u00adb\u0105 umo\u00adw\u0119,<\/span><\/strong><\/li>\n<li style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"font-size: 14px;\">wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnie przedmio\u00adto\u00adwej umo\u00adwy mu\u00adsi czy\u00adni\u0107\u00a0<strong>ca\u0142\u00adko\u00adwi\u00adcie lub cz\u0119\u00ad\u015bcio\u00adwo nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwym za\u00addo\u00ad\u015b\u0107uczy\u00adnie\u00adnie rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu<\/strong>\u00a0oso\u00adby trze\u00adciej,<\/span><\/li>\n<li style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"font-size: 14px;\">stro\u00adny za\u00adwar\u00adtej umo\u00adwy\u00a0<strong>mu\u00adsia\u00ad\u0142y wie\u00addzie\u0107 o\u00a0rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu oso\u00adby trze\u00adciej<\/strong>.<\/span><\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Ci\u0119\u00ad\u017car udo\u00adwod\u00adnie\u00adnia wy\u00ad\u017cej wy\u00admie\u00adnio\u00adnych oko\u00adlicz\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci spo\u00adczy\u00adwa na oso\u00adbie, kt\u00f3\u00adra po\u00adwo\u00ad\u0142u\u00adje si\u0119 na prze\u00adpis art. 59 k.c.\u00a0<strong>Ostat\u00adnia z\u00a0prze\u00ads\u0142a\u00adnek nie ma za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adnia, gdy umo\u00adwa by\u00ad\u0142a nie\u00adod\u00adp\u0142at\u00adna (np. umo\u00adwa da\u00adro\u00adwi\u00adzny).<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Oma\u00adwia\u00adna in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja do\u00adty\u00adczy re\u00adla\u00adcji po\u00admi\u0119\u00addzy trze\u00adma podmio\u00adta\u00admi \u2013 zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adnym, oso\u00adb\u0105, z\u00a0kt\u00f3\u00adr\u0105 zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adny za\u00adwar\u0142 umo\u00adw\u0119 oraz upraw\u00adnio\u00adnym, czy\u00adli oso\u00adb\u0105 trze\u00adci\u0105 ma\u00adj\u0105\u00adc\u0105 rosz\u00adcze\u00adnie wo\u00adbec zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adne\u00adgo. Z\u00a0upraw\u00adnie\u00adnia prze\u00adwi\u00addzia\u00adne\u00adgo w\u00a0art. 59 k.c. mo\u017c\u00adna sko\u00adrzy\u00adsta\u0107, gdy nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adno\u015b\u0107 za\u00adspo\u00adko\u00adje\u00adnia rosz\u00adcze\u00adnia jest\u00a0<strong>bez\u00adpo\u00ad\u015bred\u00adnim skut\u00adkiem wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnia za\u00adskar\u00ad\u017co\u00adnej umo\u00adwy,<\/strong> nie\u00adza\u00adle\u017c\u00adnie od wy\u00adp\u0142a\u00adcal\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adne\u00adgo.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Pod\u00adsta\u00adw\u0119 sko\u00adrzy\u00adsta\u00adnia z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. mo\u00ad\u017ce sta\u00adno\u00adwi\u0107\u00a0<strong>ka\u017c\u00adde rosz\u00adcze\u00adnie cy\u00adwil\u00adno\u00adpraw\u00adne, nie\u00adza\u00adle\u017c\u00adnie od je\u00adgo \u017ar\u00f3\u00add\u0142a<\/strong>\u00a0\u2013 \u017ar\u00f3\u00add\u0142em mo\u00ad\u017ce by\u0107 czyn\u00adno\u015b\u0107 praw\u00adna, ale te\u017c czyn nie\u00addo\u00adzwo\u00adlo\u00adny, bez\u00adpod\u00adstaw\u00adne wzbo\u00adga\u00adce\u00adnie czy orze\u00adcze\u00adnie s\u0105\u00addu.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Przed\u00adsta\u00adwia\u00adna in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja ma na ce\u00adlu za\u00adpew\u00adnie\u00adnie upraw\u00adnio\u00adne\u00admu re\u00adal\u00adne\u00adgo za\u00adspo\u00adko\u00adje\u00adnia przy\u00ads\u0142u\u00adgu\u00adj\u0105\u00adce\u00adgo mu rosz\u00adcze\u00adnia w\u00a0je\u00adgo pier\u00adwot\u00adnej po\u00adsta\u00adci, nie za\u015b w\u00a0for\u00admie za\u00adst\u0119p\u00adczej (np. w\u00a0po\u00adsta\u00adci od\u00adszko\u00addo\u00adwa\u00adnia). W\u00a0ra\u00adzie wy\u00adpe\u0142\u00adnie\u00adnia za\u00adwar\u00adtych w\u00a0nim prze\u00ads\u0142a\u00adnek, po stro\u00adnie upraw\u00adnio\u00adne\u00adgo ak\u00adtu\u00adali\u00adzu\u00adje si\u0119 pra\u00adwo \u017c\u0105\u00adda\u00adnia uzna\u00adnia da\u00adnej umo\u00adwy za bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adn\u0105 wzgl\u0119\u00addem nie\u00adgo. Upraw\u00adnie\u00adnie to wy\u00adga\u00adsa po up\u0142y\u00adwie ro\u00adku od jej za\u00adwar\u00adcia.\u00a0<strong>Bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna po\u00adle\u00adga na tym, \u017ce za\u00adskar\u00ad\u017co\u00adna umo\u00adwa jest trak\u00adto\u00adwa\u00adna ja\u00adko bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adna, ale tyl\u00adko wzgl\u0119\u00addem oso\u00adby, kt\u00f3\u00adra j\u0105 za\u00adskar\u00ad\u017cy\u00ad\u0142a. Za\u00adtem, w\u00a0sto\u00adsun\u00adku do upraw\u00adnio\u00adne\u00adgo umo\u00adwa trak\u00adto\u00adwa\u00adna b\u0119\u00addzie tak, jak\u00adby ni\u00adgdy nie zo\u00adsta\u00ad\u0142a za\u00adwar\u00adta<\/strong>.\u00a0Na\u00adto\u00admiast w\u00a0sto\u00adsun\u00adkach ze\u00adwn\u0119trz\u00adnych z\u00a0in\u00adny\u00admi oso\u00adba\u00admi, jak i\u00a0w\u00a0re\u00adla\u00adcjach po\u00admi\u0119\u00addzy stro\u00adna\u00admi, umo\u00adwa ta na\u00addal b\u0119\u00addzie wa\u017c\u00adna i\u00a0b\u0119\u00addzie wy\u00adwo\u00ad\u0142y\u00adwa\u00ad\u0142a prze\u00adwi\u00addzia\u00adne w\u00a0niej skut\u00adki na ty\u00adle, na ile da\u00adje si\u0119 to po\u00adgo\u00addzi\u0107 z\u00a0rosz\u00adcze\u00adnia\u00admi upraw\u00adnio\u00adne\u00adgo.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna umo\u00adwy a\u00a0skar\u00adga pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adska<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Mo\u00adg\u0105 po\u00adja\u00adwi\u0107 si\u0119 w\u0105t\u00adpli\u00adwo\u00ad\u015bci, czy ist\u00adnia\u00ad\u0142a po\u00adtrze\u00adba praw\u00adne\u00adgo ure\u00adgu\u00adlo\u00adwa\u00adnia in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcji bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci wzgl\u0119d\u00adnej umo\u00adwy w\u00a0art. 59 k.c., sko\u00adro oso\u00adby po\u00adkrzyw\u00addzo\u00adne na sku\u00adtek nie\u00aduczci\u00adwych czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci praw\u00adnych d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adk\u00f3w mo\u00adg\u0105 po\u00adszu\u00adki\u00adwa\u0107 ochro\u00adny praw\u00adnej na pod\u00adsta\u00adwie prze\u00adpi\u00ads\u00f3w o\u00a0skar\u00addze pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej (art. 527 i\u00a0n. k.c.). W\u00a0tym miej\u00adscu na\u00adle\u00ad\u017cy wska\u00adza\u0107, \u017ce\u00a0ac\u00adtio pau\u00adlia\u00adna\u00a0w\u00a0obec\u00adnym kszta\u0142\u00adcie mo\u00ad\u017ce nie za\u00adpew\u00adnia\u0107 na\u00adle\u00ad\u017cy\u00adtej ochro\u00adny praw\u00adnej oso\u00adbom po\u00adsia\u00adda\u00adj\u0105\u00adcym okre\u00ad\u015blo\u00adne rosz\u00adcze\u00adnie, kt\u00f3\u00adre\u00adgo za\u00adspo\u00adko\u00adje\u00adnie jest za\u00adgro\u00ad\u017co\u00adne na sku\u00adtek za\u00adwar\u00adcia i\u00a0wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnia umo\u00adwy zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adne\u00adgo z\u00a0in\u00adn\u0105 oso\u00adb\u0105. Ch\u00adro\u00adni bo\u00adwiem wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adli\u00a0<strong>je\u00addy\u00adnie w\u00a0sy\u00adtu\u00adacji nie\u00adwy\u00adp\u0142a\u00adcal\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adk\u00f3w.<\/strong> Prze\u00adpi\u00adsy o\u00a0skar\u00addze pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej za\u00adwar\u00adte w\u00a0Ko\u00addek\u00adsie zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u0144 z\u00a01933 r. udzie\u00adla\u00ad\u0142y ochro\u00adny praw\u00adnej wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adlom nie tyl\u00adko w\u00a0ra\u00adzie nie\u00adwy\u00adp\u0142a\u00adcal\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adk\u00f3w, lecz tak\u00ad\u017ce w\u00a0sy\u00adtu\u00adacji nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwo\u00ad\u015bci uczy\u00adnie\u00adnia za\u00addo\u015b\u0107 kon\u00adkret\u00adne\u00admu rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu[<span style=\"color: #000080;\">1]<\/span>. Wy\u00adda\u00adje si\u0119, \u017ce mo\u00ad\u017ce by\u0107 to jed\u00adna z\u00a0przy\u00adczyn, dla kt\u00f3\u00adrej bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. zo\u00adsta\u00ad\u0142a ure\u00adgu\u00adlo\u00adwa\u00adna ja\u00adko odr\u0119b\u00adna in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">W\u00a0tym miej\u00adscu war\u00adto przyj\u00adrze\u0107 si\u0119 bli\u00ad\u017cej r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni\u00adcom wy\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adj\u0105\u00adcym po\u00admi\u0119\u00addzy prze\u00adpi\u00adsem art. 59 k.c. a\u00a0prze\u00adpi\u00adsa\u00admi o\u00a0skar\u00addze pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Po pierw\u00adsze, na\u00adle\u00ad\u017cy wska\u00adza\u0107, \u017ce do mo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwo\u00ad\u015bci za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adnia art. 59 k.c., ina\u00adczej ni\u017c w\u00a0sy\u00adtu\u00adacji wy\u00adst\u0119\u00adpo\u00adwa\u00adnia z\u00a0rosz\u00adcze\u00adniem pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskim,\u00a0<strong>nie jest wy\u00adma\u00adga\u00adne za\u00adist\u00adnie\u00adnie nie\u00adwy\u00adp\u0142a\u00adcal\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci po stro\u00adnie d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adka.<\/strong> Na\u00adwet je\u00ad\u015bli po\u00adsia\u00adda on ma\u00adj\u0105\u00adtek, mo\u00ad\u017ce za\u00adcho\u00addzi\u0107 nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwo\u015b\u0107 spe\u0142\u00adnie\u00adnia przez nie\u00adgo okre\u00ad\u015blo\u00adne\u00adgo \u015bwiad\u00adcze\u00adnia<span style=\"color: #000080;\">[2],<\/span> np. wy\u00adma\u00adga\u00adj\u0105\u00adce\u00adgo oso\u00adbi\u00adste\u00adgo dzia\u00ad\u0142a\u00adnia d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adka.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Nad\u00adto, pod\u00adczas gdy prze\u00adpi\u00adsy do\u00adty\u00adcz\u0105\u00adce skar\u00adgi pau\u00adli\u0144\u00adskiej co do za\u00adsa\u00addy wy\u00adma\u00adga\u00adj\u0105, by d\u0142u\u017c\u00adnik oraz do\u00adko\u00adnu\u00adj\u0105\u00adca z\u00a0nim czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci praw\u00adnej oso\u00adba trze\u00adcia mie\u00adli \u015bwia\u00addo\u00admo\u015b\u0107 po\u00adkrzyw\u00addze\u00adnia wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adli,\u00a0<strong>art. 59 k.c. wy\u00adma\u00adga je\u00addy\u00adnie, by wie\u00addzie\u00adli oni o\u00a0przy\u00ads\u0142u\u00adgu\u00adj\u0105\u00adcym upraw\u00adnio\u00adne\u00admu rosz\u00adcze\u00adniu.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Co wi\u0119\u00adcej, rosz\u00adcze\u00adnie z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. mu\u00adsi by\u0107 skie\u00adro\u00adwa\u00adne prze\u00adciw\u00adko obu (wszyst\u00adkim) stro\u00adnom umo\u00adwy,<\/strong>\u00a0tym\u00adcza\u00adsem skar\u00adga pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adska, jest ad\u00adre\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adna tyl\u00adko do oso\u00adby, kt\u00f3\u00adra na sku\u00adtek czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci praw\u00adnej uzy\u00adska\u00ad\u0142a ko\u00adrzy\u015b\u0107 ma\u00adj\u0105t\u00adko\u00adw\u0105. <strong>W\u00a0prze\u00adci\u00adwie\u0144\u00adstwie do\u00a0ac\u00adtio pau\u00adlia\u00adna, art. 59 k.c. nie chro\u00adni wie\u00adrzy\u00adtel\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci pie\u00adni\u0119\u017c\u00adnych, a\u00a0wy\u00ad\u0142\u0105cz\u00adnie rosz\u00adcze\u00adnia o\u00a0\u015bwiad\u00adcze\u00adnia nie\u00adpie\u00adni\u0119\u017c\u00adne.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Ko\u00adlej\u00adn\u0105 r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni\u00adc\u0105 jest fakt, \u017ce art. 59 k.c. mo\u017c\u00adna za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u0107 je\u00addy\u00adnie w\u00a0sto\u00adsun\u00adku do umo\u00adwy.\u00a0<strong>Prze\u00adpi\u00adsu te\u00adgo nie sto\u00adsu\u00adje si\u0119 do jed\u00adno\u00adstron\u00adnych czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci praw\u00adnych czy uchwa\u0142,<\/strong> pod\u00adczas gdy po\u00adw\u00f3dz\u00adtwem pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskim mo\u017c\u00adna za\u00adskar\u00ad\u017cy\u0107 og\u00f3l\u00adnie po\u00adj\u0119\u00adt\u0105 czyn\u00adno\u015b\u0107 praw\u00adn\u0105.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>In\u00adn\u0105 kwe\u00adsti\u0105, kt\u00f3\u00adra r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni upraw\u00adnie\u00adnie z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. od upraw\u00adnie\u00adnia z\u00a0ac\u00adtio pau\u00adlia\u00adna,\u00a0jest ter\u00admin do wy\u00adst\u0105\u00adpie\u00adnia z\u00a0\u017c\u0105\u00adda\u00adniem.<\/strong> W\u00a0przy\u00adpad\u00adku art. 59 k.c. uzna\u00adnia umo\u00adwy za bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adn\u0105 nie mo\u017c\u00adna \u017c\u0105\u00adda\u0107 po up\u0142y\u00adwie ro\u00adku od jej za\u00adwar\u00adcia, na\u00adto\u00admiast w\u00a0przy\u00adpad\u00adku skar\u00adgi pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej \u2013 uzna\u00adnia czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci praw\u00adnej za bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adn\u0105 mo\u017c\u00adna do\u00adma\u00adga\u0107 si\u0119 w\u00a0ci\u0105\u00adgu 5 lat od da\u00adty tej czyn\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Mo\u00ad\u017ce si\u0119 jed\u00adnak zda\u00adrzy\u0107, \u017ce ten sam podmiot b\u0119\u00addzie upraw\u00adnio\u00adny za\u00adr\u00f3w\u00adno do wy\u00adst\u0105\u00adpie\u00adnia z\u00a0\u017c\u0105\u00adda\u00adniem z\u00a0art. 59 k.c., jak i\u00a0do wnie\u00adsie\u00adnia skar\u00adgi pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej. Ta\u00adka sy\u00adtu\u00adacja zbie\u00adgu rosz\u00adcze\u0144 na\u00adst\u0105\u00adpi, gdy w\u00a0da\u00adnym przy\u00adpad\u00adku, na sku\u00adtek za\u00adwar\u00adcia umo\u00adwy z\u00a0in\u00adn\u0105 oso\u00adb\u0105, po stro\u00adnie d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adka (zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u00adne\u00adgo) za\u00adist\u00adnie\u00adje za\u00adr\u00f3w\u00adno nie\u00admo\u017c\u00adno\u015b\u0107 \u015bwiad\u00adcze\u00adnia w\u00a0ra\u00adzie wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnia umo\u00adwy, jak i\u00a0nie\u00adwy\u00adp\u0142a\u00adcal\u00adno\u015b\u0107. W\u00f3w\u00adczas, gdy\u00adby upraw\u00adnio\u00adny nie m\u00f3g\u0142 sko\u00adrzy\u00adsta\u0107 z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. z\u00a0uwa\u00adgi na up\u0142yw rocz\u00adne\u00adgo ter\u00admi\u00adnu, b\u0119\u00addzie mia\u0142 mo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwo\u015b\u0107 do\u00adcho\u00addze\u00adnia swo\u00adich rosz\u00adcze\u0144 na pod\u00adsta\u00adwie prze\u00adpi\u00ads\u00f3w o\u00a0skar\u00addze pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej z\u00a0uwzgl\u0119d\u00adnie\u00adniem ter\u00admi\u00adnu 5-let\u00adnie\u00adgo.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Kwe\u00adstie prak\u00adtycz\u00adne<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Po\u00adw\u00f3dz\u00adtwo u\u00a0uzna\u00adnie umo\u00adwy za bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adn\u0105 na\u00adle\u00ad\u017cy wnie\u015b\u0107\u00a0<strong>prze\u00adciw\u00adko wszyst\u00adkim kon\u00adtra\u00adhen\u00adtom umo\u00adwy<\/strong>.\u00a0Stwier\u00addze\u00adnie bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci umo\u00adwy na\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adje w\u00a0try\u00adbie pro\u00adce\u00adso\u00adwym \u2013 na mo\u00adcy wy\u00adro\u00adku s\u0105\u00addo\u00adwe\u00adgo.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Z<strong>a\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adnie art. 59 k.c. nie b\u0119\u00addzie mo\u017c\u00adli\u00adwe, je\u00ad\u017ce\u00adli w\u00a0da\u00adnym przy\u00adpad\u00adku sank\u00adcja bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u00ad\u015bci wzgl\u0119d\u00adnej wy\u00adni\u00adka z\u00a0prze\u00adpi\u00adsu szcze\u00adg\u00f3l\u00adne\u00adgo,<\/strong> np. art. 916 k.c. (bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna umo\u00adwy do\u00ad\u017cy\u00adwo\u00adcia) czy art. 1024 k.c. (bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna odrzu\u00adce\u00adnia spad\u00adku)<span style=\"color: #000080;\">[3]<\/span>.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><strong>Pod\u00adsu\u00admo\u00adwa\u00adnie<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Mi\u00admo i\u017c bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna umo\u00adwy z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. mo\u00ad\u017ce wy\u00adda\u00adwa\u0107 si\u0119 in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcj\u0105 po\u00addob\u00adn\u0105 do skar\u00adgi pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskiej, tych in\u00adstru\u00admen\u00adt\u00f3w praw\u00adnych nie po\u00adwin\u00adno si\u0119 ze so\u00adb\u0105 uto\u017c\u00adsa\u00admia\u0107. Na\u00adle\u00ad\u017cy mie\u0107 na uwa\u00addze wy\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adj\u0105\u00adce mi\u0119\u00addzy ni\u00admi r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni\u00adce, zw\u0142asz\u00adcza w\u00a0za\u00adkre\u00adsie rosz\u00adcze\u0144 ja\u00adkie mo\u00adg\u0105 by\u0107 do\u00adcho\u00addzo\u00adne przy ich za\u00adsto\u00adso\u00adwa\u00adniu oraz od\u00adno\u00ad\u015bnie ter\u00admi\u00adn\u00f3w przedaw\u00adnie\u00adnia.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"color: #000080;\">[1]\u00a0<\/span>R. Trza\u00adskow\u00adski [w:]\u00a0Ko\u00addeks cy\u00adwil\u00adny. Cz\u0119\u015b\u0107 og\u00f3l\u00adna. Ko\u00admen\u00adtarz do wy\u00adbra\u00adnych prze\u00adpi\u00ads\u00f3w\u00a0, red. J. Gu\u00addow\u00adski, LEX\/el. 2018, art. 59, te\u00adza 1.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"color: #000080;\">[2]\u00a0<\/span>M. Py\u00adzia\u00adk-Szaf\u00adnic\u00adka [w:]\u00a0Ko\u00addeks cy\u00adwil\u00adny. Ko\u00admen\u00adtarz. Cz\u0119\u015b\u0107 og\u00f3l\u00adna, wyd. II, red. P. Ksi\u0119\u00ad\u017cak, War\u00adsza\u00adwa 2014, art. 59, te\u00adza 34.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><span style=\"color: #000080;\">[3]\u00a0<\/span>A. Ja\u00adnas [w:]\u00a0Ko\u00addeks cy\u00adwil\u00adny. Ko\u00admen\u00adtarz. Tom I. Cz\u0119\u015b\u0107 og\u00f3l\u00adna (art. 1-125), red. M. Fras, M. Hab\u00addas, War\u00adsza\u00adwa 2018, art. 59.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Skar\u00adga pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adska to nie je\u00addy\u00adna in\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja Ko\u00addek\u00adsu cy\u00adwil\u00adne\u00adgo ma\u00adj\u0105\u00adca za za\u00adda\u00adnie ochro\u00adn\u0119 wie\u00adrzy\u00adcie\u00adli przed frau\u00adda\u00adcyj\u00adny\u00admi dzia\u00ad\u0142a\u00adnia\u00admi d\u0142u\u017c\u00adni\u00adk\u00f3w. In\u00adnym in\u00adstru\u00admen\u00adtem praw\u00adnym, wy\u00admie\u00adrzo\u00adnym prze\u00adciw\u00adko oso\u00adbom uni\u00adka\u00adj\u0105\u00adcym wy\u00adko\u00adna\u00adnia swo\u00adich zo\u00adbo\u00adwi\u0105\u00adza\u0144, jest bez\u00adsku\u00adtecz\u00adno\u015b\u0107 wzgl\u0119d\u00adna umo\u00adwy z\u00a0art. 59 k.c. In\u00adsty\u00adtu\u00adcja ta na pierw\u00adszy rzut oka mo\u00ad\u017ce wy\u00adda\u00adwa\u0107 si\u0119 \u0142u\u00addz\u0105\u00adco po\u00addob\u00adna do po\u00adw\u00f3dz\u00adtwa pau\u00adlia\u0144\u00adskie\u00adgo. Wy\u00adst\u0119\u00adpu\u00adj\u0105 jed\u00adnak mi\u0119\u00addzy ni\u00admi istot\u00adne r\u00f3\u017c\u00adni\u00adce, kt\u00f3\u00adre [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":2508,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_et_pb_use_builder":"","_et_pb_old_content":"","_et_gb_content_width":"","footnotes":""},"categories":[70],"tags":[],"ppma_author":[301],"class_list":["post-12306","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-publikacje","author-filipiak-babicz-legal","et-has-post-format-content","et_post_format-et-post-format-standard"],"_vci_translations":{"pl":12306},"_vci_seo":[],"_vci_author":{"id":1,"name":"Wojciech K.","slug":"n0timportant"},"acf":[],"authors":[{"term_id":301,"user_id":0,"is_guest":1,"slug":"filipiak-babicz-legal","display_name":"Filipiak Babicz Legal","avatar_url":{"url":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/wp-content\/uploads\/2022\/08\/filipiak.jpg","url2x":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/wp-content\/uploads\/2022\/08\/filipiak.jpg"},"first_name":"","last_name":"","user_url":"","description":""}],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12306","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=12306"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12306\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":13756,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12306\/revisions\/13756"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/2508"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=12306"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=12306"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=12306"},{"taxonomy":"author","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dev2.bpcc.org.pl\/pl\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/ppma_author?post=12306"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}